The owner family came from Brooklyn, NYC, so they serve authentic Brooklyn-style pizza. We tried the classic cheese pizza and the white pizza, and both were absolutely fantastic. The restaurant is quite small, but they have a spacious patio table and a few small tables outside, making it a great spot for a family dinner. I had the pleasure of chatting with the owner, who was incredibly friendly and welcoming. The pizza guy, Eddie, showed me his pizza-making process, and I thoroughly enjoyed watching him work. (You can see everything!) We also ordered the zeppole, which were so delicious!
Overview
Miei Amici Pizzeria brings a welcoming neighborhood dining experience to St Johns, Florida, offering a place where guests can enjoy the familiar comfort of pizza and Italian-inspired favorites in a relaxed setting. Located at 3735 Longleaf Pine Pkwy Ste 225, St Johns, FL 32259, United States, this pizzeria provides a convenient location for families, friends, and local diners looking for a casual meal with a friendly atmosphere.
The appeal of Miei Amici Pizzeria comes from its focus on classic pizzeria traditions while creating a comfortable environment for everyday dining. A good pizza restaurant is often defined by the balance between quality ingredients, thoughtful preparation, and a menu that gives guests plenty of choices, and these elements are central to what diners look for when choosing their next meal. Whether stopping by for a quick lunch, planning a relaxed dinner, or sharing food with a group, the menu offers the kind of variety that makes a pizzeria a popular gathering place.
Pizza remains the heart of the experience, with attention placed on familiar flavors that appeal to both longtime Italian food enthusiasts and casual guests. From traditional favorites to specialty selections, a well-crafted pizza depends on the harmony between the crust, sauce, cheese, and toppings. The right combination creates a satisfying meal that can be enjoyed by individuals, couples, and families alike. Along with pizza, guests often appreciate a broader selection of Italian-style dishes that add flexibility to the dining experience.
The location in St Johns makes Miei Amici Pizzeria an accessible option for nearby residents who want a local restaurant with a comfortable setting. Restaurants that become part of a community often stand out because they provide more than just food; they offer a familiar place where people can meet, relax, and enjoy quality time together. The atmosphere, service experience, and consistency of the menu all contribute to how customers remember their visit.
When considering restaurant reviews, diners often pay attention to factors such as food quality, menu variety, convenience, and overall value. Miei Amici Pizzeria reflects the qualities many guests appreciate in a neighborhood pizzeria: approachable Italian flavors, a welcoming dining environment, and a location that fits naturally into the St Johns community. Whether visiting for a casual meal or ordering pizza to share at home, the restaurant provides an inviting option for those craving classic pizzeria favorites.
A standout restaurant experience is built through attention to detail, from the preparation of each dish to the way guests feel during their visit. Miei Amici Pizzeria offers a setting where pizza lovers and Italian food fans can enjoy familiar flavors while creating memorable dining moments. Its St Johns location continues to make it a convenient choice for anyone searching for a local pizzeria with a comfortable atmosphere and a menu designed for different occasions.
Good to know
Service options
✓ Outdoor seating ✓ Curbside pickup ✓ No-contact delivery ✓ Delivery ✓ Drive-through ✓ Onsite services ✓ Takeout ✓ Dine-inHighlights
✓ Fast service ✓ SportsPopular for
✓ Lunch ✓ Dinner ✓ Solo diningAccessibility
✓ Wheelchair accessible entrance ✓ Wheelchair accessible parking lot ✓ Wheelchair accessible restroom ✓ Wheelchair accessible seatingOfferings
✓ Alcohol ✓ Beer ✓ Comfort food ✓ Quick bite ✓ Small platesDining options
✓ Lunch ✓ Dinner ✓ Catering ✓ Counter service ✓ Dessert ✓ Seating ✓ No Table serviceAmenities
✓ RestroomAtmosphere
✓ Casual ✓ QuietCrowd
✓ Family-friendly ✓ LGBTQ+ friendly ✓ Transgender safespacePlanning
✓ Accepts reservationsPayments
✓ Credit cards ✓ Debit cardsChildren
✓ Good for kidsParking
✓ Free parking lot ✓ Free street parking ✓ ParkingPets
✓ Dogs allowed outsidePhotos
1 / 4
Location
Reviews
- No ratings yet 435 reviews
I fear I am falling in love with this place - and it’s nearby?! Dangerous combo. I can hands down say this is the best pizza around - no doubt! I visited NYC and haven’t stopped thinking about the pizza I had while I was there… nothing in Jax/st John’s compared - Miei Amici Pizzeria hit that craving perfectly. The ingredients are extremely fresh and you can tell this pizza has real roots behind it. I couldn’t even take a picture before I downed a slice. The crunch of the crust and the soft cheesy top is what I was constantly searching for and no longer have to. Consistently amazing. Owner was kind and offered some friendly chats while I was paying - appreciate the tattoo love I’ll be back. Again.
Wonderful family NYC style pizza. Want to get something for the family or to share at the party? This place will not disappoint. Great customer service. No need to get pizza anywhere else.
This is a newly discovered pizza joint for me. I didn’t really know what to expect, but my buddy said I’d like it, so I gave it a shot. Tons of options on the menu but the chicken parm pie was calling my name. They were quick, friendly, and were happy to answer any questions I had about their menu. The pie was amazing. Hands down the best I’ve had in my area. Every time I suggest a pizza place now, it’s this pizzeria. Just check out this pie, it’s a masterpiece. Perfectly cooked, toppings are quality and the undercarriage is cooked to perfection with minimal flop. Seriously. Gotta give this place a go.
Hidden gem found St. Johns, FL. This Chicago girl was just passing through and can I say I am so happy we stopped in. If you have been searching for that NY style of Pizza look no further than Miei Amici . The Alfredo Pizza was delicious, crispy and perfectly balanced !! And this is coming from a Chicago pizza girl to my core! Garlic knots some full of flavor and fluffy. The staff were incredibly friendly and helpful with recommendations. You can tangibly feel the love that’s being poured out in this place. Restaurant was incredibly clean and beautifully set up. Restrooms were also clean and wheelchair accessible. It’s such a welcoming vibe here. Loved the outdoor sitting area and order pickup window. If you are living in Northern Florida or just passing through, stop and check out Miei Amici Pizzeria!! You won’t be disappointed!!
Hidden Italian gem in St. John’s county. Pizza is amazing and makes me feel like I am back in NY. Love the crust! Highly recommend if looking for great pizza. Try the drunken Nona and the NY style margarita pizza as well.